Please help us identify bugs and broken links in the site by writing to vikram@hpk.co.in

The Book of Eli: The Road for Dummies

Book-of-EliIf George W. Bush has left one legacy to the arts, it’s that under his administration more films about the Apocalypse and ecological destruction went into production than under any other presidency.

The latest to be released is the Hughes Brothers' The Book of Eli. Consider this tepid offering "Cormac McCarthy Lite."

Like McCarthy's Pulitzer-Prize-winning The Road (and its recent first-rate screen adaptation), The Book of Eli takes place after civilization's been decimated. Of the few survivors, a huge percentage have become rapists and cannibals. What's worse is that these remnants of mankind are also smelly. Apparently without access to commercials for Colgate and Dial soap, hygiene has gone the way of the dodo.

Additionally, both offerings share a religious core. In The Road, a father is trying to get his son, a possible Christ figure, to a warmer environment. In The Book of Eli, the taciturn Christ figure with a mission, Eli (Denzel Washington), is trying to transport the last surviving copy of the Bible to what's left of San Francisco.

Hey, what happened to all the other copies? Glad you asked. All the millions upon millions of Bibles that have been published throughout the ages have been destroyed, apparently because these tomes have been blamed for the rack and ruin of humanity. The Lord's Prayer has been judged calamitous.

Well, with that premise and an opening slower-paced than molasses in January, we get to see Eli kill a hairless cat with an arrow for dinner; ambulate past hundreds of skeleton-filled, burnt-out autos; and then finally clean his genitals with a KFC towelette, which brings up the question: Who at KFC approved this product placement? Now every time we pass one of these fast-food eateries, we're going to think of reeking testicles. That's an appetite whetter.

Anyway, a very nasty man named Carnegie (Gary Oldman) wants to get his hands on Eli's Bible so he can use the Word to rule a dystopia of his own making. Uh-oh!

Poor Carnegie! He doesn't realize that Eli is a soldier of God, who with his mean sword and a few bullets, can wipe out armies of meanies. If you don't believe me, just you watch Eli cut off a hand or disjoint a head or shoot someone in the crotch.

Along for the blood-soaked ride is a pair of very bad actresses: Jennifer Beals as Carnegie's blind mistress and Mila Kunis as her bartending daughter. If two performances ever could cause you to question the existence of God, these would be the two.

Yet with stunning cinematography by Don Burgess (Forrest Gump), breathtaking production design by Gae Buckley (He's Just Not That Into You), and state-of-the-art visual effects by Jon Farhat (The Mask), you at times almost forget how humorless, repugnant, and unnecessary this whole product is.

Only near the finale, with the appearance of two top-notch thespians, Michael Gambon and Frances De la Tour, as George and Martha, aging, lovable, man-eating survivalists, does the film really come alive in a totally enjoyable manner.

This is, however, a case of "too little, too late" unless quickly edited dismemberment, misogyny, and commercialized spirituality, all enacted to an annoying score composed by Atticus Ross, is your cup of tea. If so, drink up. - Brandon Judell

brandon.jpg

Mr. Judell is featured in Rosa von Praunheim's forthcoming documentary New York Memories. In the spring, he'll be teaching "The Image of the Jew in Post-World War II European Cinema" and "Gay and Lesbian Literature" at The City College of New York. He has written on film for The Village Voice, indieWire, Detour, and The Advocate, and is anthologized in Cynthia Fuchs's Spike Lee Interviews (University Press of Mississippi).

Comments

How's that global warming

How's that global warming working for you knucklehead!

Just fine...

If films like this keep coming out Global Warming would be a mercy killing.

Book of Eli

I have to completely disagree with you on almost every level. I don't see why it is so unbelievable that all the copies of the Bible have been exterminated, nor should that impair your movie experience. Don't you kind of have to buy into some stories a little bit to get into him. The Bible issue sounds ridiculous but you're okay with the idea of an apocalypse? Also, just because Eli says it's the last copy, does that make it so? Do you think he's spoken to every single survivor in the world?
And most of the remaining people are rapists and maneaters? We did see, what? Two of the hundreds of people in the movie in an attempted rape scene? We do know of, what? A handful of people that we knew for a fact turned to cannibalism? And, really, the performance of two of the actresses made you question the existence of god? That is the most unnecessary comment that I have possibly ever read in a movie review. I just wanna type it again. Made you question the existence of God. Wow.
These opinions you formed also seem to be under the assumption that what we see in the movie is similar to what's going on everywhere else in the world.
That seems like an awful idea and I couldn't disagree with you more about the shortcomings of this movie. Thanks, and have a great day, JTB

I'm guessing you liked "The Passion of The Christ" as well...

Only a blind born-again, desperate to see the Bible portrayed in a heroic light on the big screen, could possibly scrap together some nice things to say about this cinematic disaster.

Mr. Brantley, if you believe in God and are willing to enjoy this contrived mockery of a movie then why don't you accept what The Lord's messenger has to say? Eli, God's prophet in this misguided film, is informed by a voice that he is in possession of the last existing Bible. The Voice's words, not mine or the reviewer's, hence... he has to take it West, they made a crappy movie about it and we all had to suffer. My favorite flaw was the "surprise" ending which came out of left field because... it contradicted the rest of the film. Now that's movie magic. A suspension of disbelief shouldn't require putting one's brain on cruise control.

Thank you for your heartfelt response, but . . .

please look up the meaning of "irony."

By the way, I do not find it unbelievable that all of the copies of the Bible were destroyed except Eli's. In fact, the reason they were all destroyed is one of the few clever moments in a rather bankrupt screenplay.

As for Mila Kunis's performance turning me into an atheist, odder occurrences have sadly taken place in this peculiar world of ours.

you are soo clueless

hahah you are seriously a fucking idiot. your two reasons for not liking this movie was the fact that he used a KFC towlette to clean his balls and the fact he has the last bible. okay, it'sa movie asshole? you gotta try to believe some stuff.

Believing other stuff...

...like dudes walking on water and raising from the dead? Everyone believes some wacky things, pal.

P.S. I am not the reviewer, just someone who suffered through this film and couldn't agree with him more.

best comment on Eli comes from The Road

although Eli is not the worst film in its genre, without Densil it might have been. defenately on par with the last terminator. I enjoyed Gary Oldmans sidekick wistleing spagetty western tunes.admitadly, had I not seen The Road the night before i might have been able to expect less.
however it was the script of the road, which i refuse to believe was coincidence, that best sumarised the book of Eli.
"whats wrong with Eli"
"dont hold his hand"

Please Check Your Spelling Before Adding Comments...

I enjoy the comments and discourse, but please check your grammar before posting comments. Thanks. D

Densil (Denzel), spagetty (spaghetti), admitadly (admittedly), wistleing (whistling), etc.

haha

people are calling this movie bad because it has some science fiction in it... and a blind man walking around the world... but they give movies like avatar, narnia, star wars etc. etc.... awesome reviews but because the bible is not directly alluded to they are awesome and this is terrible... gg atheists gg

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Back to Top